Alan White - Lights Out

 Alan White


When Chris Welch commented on Bill Bruford leaving Yes in the summer of 1972 he said it was like Rolls quitting Royce.   

Over the years since then all the talk has been about how complex Yes's music was by then and what a mammoth task it was for Alan to come in and learn all that stuff in a few days which he did in time for Dallas.

That was only a small part of the story the reality was the way Bill and Chris worked was entirely atypical.  To break into that required a complete rethink for the entire band. Chris towards the end, on the fortieth anniversary of the Yes Album acknowledged that. Rick in late '72 found the change unsettling. It was as if the foundations of a building had been completely remodelled and the upper floors didn't sit properly afterwards. 

When you sat in the Wembley Arena in 1977 and listened to Alan count in Starship Trooper you knew the journey had been made. Trooper, Siberian, Good People, And You and I, were BETTER than the originals. Alan and Chris made the band more majestic more spiritual more moving on these pieces. But it was a real exercise in patience and commitment to the band to get to that point.

When Chris was interviewed in May 1973 when they were rehearsing for a new album, as we called them in those days, and asked how they were going. Chris said they would come away with something achieved every day whereas in the past arguments made the going slow, some days nothing got done. Maybe they should have argued more but Alan's approach was to vibe things up and Chris was still learning how to fit around the new drummer. He got a parking ticket the day of that interview. 

Looking back Alan had to completely rethink his approach and having been a Beatle Drummer, with all the kudos and openings that brought, its amazing he stuck with it. It was not an easy gig.

What really began back then was unswerving loyalty to the cause that was their right to the end. 

Relayer showed how quickly he could learn and that sharp clean sound on the drums was back for Sound Chaser and To Be Over. 

The solo album showed what an intuitive drummer he was and somehow the mic'ing of the kit caught this wonderful three dimensional warm musical vibe that the band was not able to capture. Oddly much later capturing Alan at his best also came outside of the Band. 

if the live act of White/Squire was on the money by '77 three years later they were veritable monsters in the studio when what began at Redan with 10 pieces morphed into Trevor and Geoff joining them. Messiah and Lens had that hard edged playing with tons of space, this was a new forward looking rhythm section with the values of Bill/Chris in there. The sound was clean the playing energetic, certain, Offord was there along with Horn T. 

Sadly it was not until Keys that freewheeling open ended approach returned where the music was both expansive and controlled and routed in the two of them. 

However with the accidental Yes of Rabin Alan showed yet again what a huge musician he was. He completely reinvented his style with only brief moments (Intro to Changes) where 70's Yes was on show and boy could he swing. No one got Rhythm of Love like Alan. Whatever else one thinks about those years, Alan always delivered what was needed.

Fast forward to 1995/6 and he showed with Keys, one of his greatest performances,  how much he had developed something Rick acknowledged publicly. 

Artistically Keys was really the follow up to Drama but with a different front line. Listen to criminally overlooked pieces like Footprints. Alan was spartan but powerful and Chris would nibble his way round the piece or just funk it out. This was the kind of understanding that made music making seem effortless but it gave such certainty to A.W.H. and they were much more playful and inventive in the way that Yes should always be with such a certain powerful foundation. What a talent to play Owner, It Can Happen and this stuff. 

There was also something else which I learned through Alan, to hear the drummer playing the melody,  listen to Bring Me To Power and at different times they are all playing the rhythm and they are all playing the melody, phenomenal stuff.  

Whilst the top line was fractious coming and going and uncertain, Alan and Chris always turned up and when Yes tried a fourth wind with HSW W was there. 

Personally I think those four years off the road were not helpful, these guys needed to work and stay on their game but from 2008 right through to 2014 Alan and Chris were the foundation stone of all that touring and then out of the blue came Levin Torn White. Like that project from the 70's it got so much more out of Alan than the contemporaneous work the band were undertaking and its difficult to get your head round the idea that the same man played drums on Heaven and Earth and LTW.

He worked with others before Yes, you may have heard of them, and during, there was a really long piece a jam with the late Paul Kossoff I recall on Koss's own album. 

Colston Hall under the Dean Canopy 1975, Starship the encore at Wembley'77, Colston Hall with Benoit, Oliver and Astral Traveller and the magic hat in Glasgow in 2015 with young William on the Bass. Thank you for such wonderful memories.  

At the end of every concert in the UK in 2011 Chris thanked us for our commitment. I reciprocate that to you.

So its "Lights Out' Alan you have pushed the envelope, shot out across the horizon and disappeared "Onward" with the "Keys To Ascension." 


.    



 





 




    



  




Comments

  1. Thanks, Michelle, for those words.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello. I found the sign in to make a comment a bit difficult this time. Not sure if I am adding a comment or a reply to Henry. My first memory of Alan's playing was on Yessongs which was electric. I understand there were initial problems given the three days to learn the repertoire. The live versions of Siberian Khatru and Yours Is No Disgrace were on another level. The live film that accompanied that era of playing shows Alan happily playing a triangle in the section after the explosive start. As yes progressed the live version of Ritual and the percussive section was another high point. I first saw Yes live in person in 1977. The bass pedal and bass drum was a kick to the stomach. The 1978 'In The Round' tour saw the band arguably at their best live. What might have sounded weak on Tormato took on a new life live. On the Silent Wings of Freedom saw Alan and the band rocking again. Thinking of the fluidity of Alan's playing on the 1972/3 live YIND puts me in mind of his playing on Rick's Six Wives. The drum sticks flew of the drum skins. Well done to Alan for sticking with Yes through all the ups and downs of the band's history. Thanks for your article Michelle as something to respond to.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great to hear your thoughts. I was still at boarding school when Alan joined the Band and we were taken to London in December of 1972 to visit the Houses of Parliament as I did British Constitution as an "A" Level. I must have taken my radio with me because I distinctly remember hearing a BBC Show recorded, I think, in Manchester and they put phase on Alan's drums. It was a really interesting and successful experiment.

      Good People sounded completely different with Alan on the riser and YIND ROCKED. Indeed years later when Trevor Rabin lead the band Alan was a high point on all those albums.

      I enjoyed your final remark as Henry knows the only thing that interests me is the music and if any of them excell I say so and conversely if any of them are less than good I say so.

      Check out Billy Sherwood's tribute album for "On The Silent Wings" Pat plays the keys and Jon Davison sings. Finally Tony an album I have gone back to is "I". It ages well and has some phenomenal musical ideas on it.

      Delete
  3. Hello again Michelle. I mentioned Alan playing the triangle but neglected to say specifically this was And You And I. AYAI is one of my top fave Yes songs live. But… and I'd be interested in your view here as I have never seen it discussed. For me the Yessongs (album and film) versions really soar. Very, very emotional performances. And for are the ultimate performances for this song. I'm talking of the explosive bits where bass pedals, string synths and pedal steel unite. In later live versions Steve Howe seems to add extra squiggly bits on the steel which to me sound a bit jokey. It is noticeable around the nine or ten minute mark depending on which live version. For me it breaks the climatic moment. I have never liked it and for it kind of ruins it. I know it is their song / composition. And they deliver it how they see fit. The squiggly addition is so different I'm surprised no-one has mentioned it. Maybe I am on my own in this respect. Have you noticed this variation and what do you think. It seemed to emerge late 1970s and has been a feature ever since.

    ReplyDelete
  4. HI Tony, will respond in full (currently on holiday). I also have a problem that Facebook have suddenly decided my blog links are spam and retroactively blocked this entry on Facebook Best Wishes Michelle

    ReplyDelete
  5. "And You And I" has a fascinating construction. The version offered on CTTE starts with a very pastoral vibe and "Cord of Life" is a very advanced folk song. "Eclipse" by contrast is symphonic. The transition is one of the most sophisticated in the progressive rock genre. Unsurprisingly it’s the way ABWH played it.

    When Alan went out on tour they opted for the alternative version they had recorded and that enables them to recapitulate the Eclipse theme three times giving it a grander more symphonic feel. There is no doubt though that by 1977 several pieces from the big three where being played with much more power and emotion than the studio version. Siberian/And You and I/Starship Trooper/Good People and that is because of Alan's more laid back rooted style of playing. My recollection of Yessongs is "And You and I" was one of the triumphs. I agree with Dan Hedges that overall the material sounded like "it had been recorded on a phone in Grand Central Station" and I also agree with Alan that it was recorded too soon after he joined. On the variations that Steve plays on AY& I agree with you its kind of "playing to the gallery stuff." The sort of thing that Nigel Kennedy would do with his classical repertoire.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for your comment. Yessongs was the introduction to Yes for me so it became the benchmark. The sound recording didn't occur to me until it was mentioned. Each track from the classic trilogy seemed to be brought more to life. It was Alan who I heard first and there was a fluidity that matched the band. It was all fast and furious from Siberian Khatru to YIND with some lovely ambient moments. They knew how to suspend a moment and then come crashing in. The highs and lows of emotion. I had heard nothing like it in one band. I couldn't afford Yessongs at the time so I bought one of the three albums – Fragile. I was initially disappointed because Yessongs was so electric and energetic. Bill was a completely different drummer with all the intricacies of percussion. Gradually I really came around to Eddie Offord's studio production and the crispness of the individual instruments. It was a real learning journey to appreciate the two sides of studio and live. I agree starting with Eclipse is so powerful, then calm, then the build up. On The Word Is Live the introduction to SK is entitled Apocalypse which integrates Eclipse and again a powerful set up that then suspends before crashing in. I like your comparison to virtuoso performers souping up the performance. But I love the Yessongs LP and Film performance of AYAI the best. All the emotion in Steve's face as he pulls everything he can out of the pedal steel. It goes high to low like its crying. It's goose bumps hair on the back of your neck stuff. I'm afraid the faux scary squiggles of late 70s to date don't work for me. If the live sound quality on Yessongs is questioned then we have to talk bootlegs and other soundboard recordings. The seven from the progeny collection has some strong contenders. The 2003 concert programme features a discussion regarding bootlegs with a former band manager (I guess Brian Lane) stating 'you're no-one until you've been bootlegged'. The band seemed to accept it as a compliment. Despite questions around Tormato the 1978/79 in the round tour probably saw the classic yes at the top of their live game. Thanks to the BBC it was recorded. The Tormato tracks stood up well. Apart from CoH – why did they choose to play that live!? :-) Maybe it was an indicator of the band parting ways. Rick and Jon going softer and the rest wanting to rock out. Anyway in my view 1970-1980 saw the best of Yes both in the studio and live. I first saw Yes in 1977 and they played AYAI and CTTE. It was my first proper gig. It was deafening. You felt the bass pedals and drums in you body. The guitars screeching in your ear. Unforgettable. I have developed a varied collection but Yes will always be special. All the best. Tony

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was at Wembley for 28/10/78 the show that was recorded for the Tommy Vance show. Starship Trooper and the reaction to it was unforgettable. But the cracks were there. A lot of Tormato was not played.

    Essentially Jon Anderson instead of directing the band collectively decided he was a writer of songs and apart from Rick the songs he wrote from that day until this have been rejected by the band. The only time his 'song' work has received wholesale acceptance from the collective was the material he vibed up with the two support musicians for ABWH, so that was done sleight of hand.

    They rejected his ideas in 1979,1991 and 2008. When they did Keys Studio, Ladder and Magnification there was more of that collective vibe again, whatever you think of the music but that had a lot to do on the first two with Billy Sherwood glueing them altogether.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rise and Fall - Making Deeper Connections

Levin Torn White